Top 10 Reasons to Choose Between Cricut and Brother Scan and Cut for Your Next Cutting Machine Adventure

Are you excited to begin your crafting journey, but unsure whether to go with Cricut or Brother Scan and Cut? You’re not alone! Many crafters face this decision, with both brands offering unique features that can enhance your crafting skills. Whether you're creating personalized gifts, designing stickers, or tackling crafty DIY projects, understanding the differences can help you make a more informed choice. Let’s explore the top ten reasons to guide your selection.

1. User-Friendly Interface

Ease of use is crucial when choosing a cutting machine.

Cricut machines are operated through an app on your computer, tablet, or mobile phone, making crafting a breeze! Users can effortlessly choose from a variety of materials and tweak settings with ease, ensuring a seamless creative experience.

On the flip side, Brother Scan and Cut features an intuitive LCD display. This allows you to create custom designs directly on the machine. It’s especially useful for crafters who prefer a standalone experience without a computer.

2. Versatility in Cutting

One of the standout differences between Cricut and Brother Scan and Cut is their cutting capabilities.

Cricut machines are known for their precision. They can effortlessly cut intricate designs from various materials like vinyl, cardstock, and leather. For example, some Cricut models can cut materials as thin as 0.1 mm and as thick as 2.4 mm, making them ideal for detailed projects.

In contrast, Brother Scan and Cut is unique because it allows you to scan images and cut them out directly. If you have a hand-drawn design, you can scan it, and the machine will create a cutting file. This feature is vital for those looking to duplicate existing artwork easily. The Scan and Cut is capable of cutting up to 3mm thick.

3. Software and Design Options

Both Cricut and Brother machines come with specialized software, which can shape your crafting experience greatly.

Cricut Design Space is an incredibly user-friendly online platform that opens up a world of creativity with access to thousands of images and pre-made designs! Some users have reported having access to over 100,000 images, which can truly spark your imagination and make your projects a breeze. Keep in mind, a subscription is required for all machines. While you can import your own designs, it's important to note that this feature now incurs a charge unless you own an older registered model.

On the other hand, Brother Scan and Cut shines with CanvasWorkspace! This software supports a variety of file types and offers versatile design tools. You can import files in formats like SVG, DXF, and PNG, giving you an incredible level of creative freedom. Importing is completely free, and while you have the option to use their designs, most are free. However, they also provide premium designs available for purchase.

4. Built-in Scanning Feature

A major selling point for Brother Scan and Cut is its built-in scanning feature.

This allows you to scan any image and convert it into a cutting file quickly. You can easily replicate stickers, drawings, or even cut out printed images. For example, if you find a design you love on paper, you can cut it out without redrawing it. Cricut, unfortunately, lacks this capability, making Brother a more appealing option for those who prioritize scanning.

5. Portability

Are you a crafter who enjoys working on the go?

Cricut stand out here with the Cricut Joy being especially compact and lightweight, perfect for crafting in various locations. It's ideal for simple projects like cards or labels.

6. Material Compatibility

Material compatibility can enhance your crafting capabilities.

Cricut machines work with various materials, including specialty items such as Infusible Ink. They can even use Smart Materials, allowing for matless cutting. Reports suggest that Cricut can handle over 300 different materials!

Brother Scan and Cut shines when it comes to fabric cutting. It can cut multiple fabric layers with precision, making it the go-to choice for sewists and mixed-media artists. For example, it can handle materials like felt and cotton directly, which few other consumer machines can match.

7. Cost

Price is a significant factor when selecting a cutting machine.

Cricut has a range of models that fit various budgets. Basic models can start around £150, while advanced machines can go up to £350 or more. The Mats for the Cricut are also substantially cheaper than the Scan and Cut

Brother Scan and Cut typically requires a higher initial investment, with prices starting around £200 and reaching £600. However, many users feel the return on investment is worth it due to its scanning abilities and included software. I would advise if you can afford one with an auto blade they are much easier to use and as the Scan and Cut Mats are a lot more expensive it minimises the risk of ruining them.

8. Community and Support

Joining a supportive crafting community can make your journey more enjoyable.

Cricut hosts a large user community with numerous blogs, forums, and social media groups. These resources provide a wealth of shared projects, tips, and hacks. For instance, many users actively share their unique designs, offering valuable insights.

Brother Scan and Cut has a smaller community, but it also has plenty of support resources. While both brands offer excellent customer support, Cricut's larger community may provide quicker help and a wider variety of project showcases.

9. Upgradability

As technology progresses, the ability to upgrade your cutting machine is appealing.

Cricut routinely updates its software, bringing in new features and capabilities. For example, recent updates have added more design functionalities and improved user experience.

Brother also offers firmware updates, but the built-in scanning technology can complicate potential upgrades. Users might find that future improvements are less intuitive than Cricut’s consistent additions.

10. Personal Crafting Style

Ultimately, the ideal cutting machine for you hinges on your personal crafting preferences.

If you enjoy creating intricate designs and want a plethora of ready-made files, Cricut is likely the right choice. Its intuitive design options cater well to those who appreciate crafted elegance.

On the other hand, if you value scanning features or work frequently with fabrics, Brother Scan and Cut could be your best bet. Its unique capabilities make it a versatile tool in the hands of fabric artists and hobbyists alike.

Cricut cutting machine ready for creative projects

Crafting Your Decision

Deciding between Cricut and Brother Scan and Cut can be both exciting and overwhelming. Each machine offers distinctive features tailored to different crafting needs.

Take your time to explore each brand, evaluate your unique crafting style, and consider factors like ease of use, cutting capabilities, and community support. By carefully assessing these elements, you can discover the perfect machine to fuel your creativity. Happy crafting!

Brother Scan and Cut machine showcasing a creative design